The Magic Hour

The Magic Hour

Share this post

The Magic Hour
The Magic Hour
Look Where You're Going and Keep Moving

Look Where You're Going and Keep Moving

luck, envy, and other fictions.

Caroline Cala Donofrio's avatar
Caroline Cala Donofrio
Jun 23, 2025
∙ Paid
117

Share this post

The Magic Hour
The Magic Hour
Look Where You're Going and Keep Moving
26
6
Share

I roll out the door like Oscar the Grouch emerging from his trashcan — disheveled, with an air of curmudgeon.

It’s barely 8 a.m., yet the day’s already hotter than the devil’s mouth. The train took its sweet time showing up, then inexplicably sat in a tunnel. I’m running late, I’m hot, and the hair not stuck to my sweaty forehead has morphed into a voluminous triangle that, were it to appear on a cartoon, would signal they were going through it. This is not my Best Self.

I’m headed to breakfast with a publicist, where she’ll talk about her clients so I can hopefully write about them. In honor of the occasion, I’m sporting a dress with a peplum, which is decidedly not my style but might be the style of whoever it is I’m trying to be. I routinely feel like I am cosplaying adulthood, something I fear I may never outgrow.

This is a peplum dress, in case you, like my husband, were like “wha?”

I arrive to find the publicist already seated, looking prim and fresh. Silk dress, neat hair, glowing complexion. The restaurant — her choice — looks like it hails from the time of Paul Revere, the kind of place where toast means a slab of sourdough three inches thick, and a fried egg comes nestled in its own little cast-iron pan. Over the course of our conversation, she reveals that she lives nearby, in a home she and her husband are in the process of renovating.

She gestures animatedly as she speaks, her diamond solitaire glinting like a scale model of Epcot. On the tabletop, her phone background bears a photo of two smiling children. Based on her LinkedIn profile, I surmise that we are about the same age. Yet we present as two different species.

We part ways and I head to work, marinating in the assumption that this woman has everything I want, everything that remains maddeningly elusive. I feel rankled, mystified, frustrated at my perceived lack of traction. For the rest of the day, a thought drifts in and out of my mind: Some people are just lucky.

The following week, I reach out about one of her clients and receive an automated bounce-back. Soon after, her colleague informs me that just a few days after our meeting, the publicist tragically and unexpectedly died.

*

I’ve thought of her many times in the decade since. I think of her whenever I pass through her neighborhood, or the corner of the restaurant where we met. I think of her at this time of year, as the air grows thick and hot. Though we spent a grand total of ninety minutes in each other’s company, I’ve thought of her more than figures who shared whole seasons of my life.

In truth, I am thinking less about her — a person I barely knew — than I am about the myth of her, and the ways it affected me. I reflect on the envy I felt without knowing her story, or the realities of her life. About our inability to predict, or control, the plot. About the parameters of luck, if such a thing exists.

*

I’ve shared it before, and am far from the first to tell it, but the story bears repeating.

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Caroline Cala Donofrio
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share